Former Special Prosecutor Martin Amidu has strongly criticized Circuit Court Judge Samuel Bright Acquah, accusing him of twisting Ghana’s Constitution into something resembling George Orwell’s Animal Farm, where some citizens are treated as “more equal than others.”
Amidu argued that Judge Acquah acted beyond his authority by using bail denial as a form of punishment—something Amidu claims is unconstitutional and reflects authoritarian tendencies.
“Judge Acquah’s ruling effectively reduces the 1992 Constitution to a dictatorship, giving a circuit court judge unchecked power over citizens’ liberties,” Amidu stated.
He further took issue with the judge’s literary reference to Animal Farm, suggesting Acquah had misread or misunderstood the book.
“How can someone who hasn’t properly read Orwell’s Animal Farm cite it as justification for denying bail?” Amidu asked. “This is not just about literature; it's about upholding the rule of law.”
Amidu warned that such rulings signal a dangerous shift in Ghana’s justice system—one that mirrors Orwell’s infamous line: "All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others."
Background to the Controversy
The case at the center of this debate involves Kwame Baffoe, popularly known as Abronye DC, who is the Bono Regional Chairman of the ruling New Patriotic Party (NPP). Abronye was recently denied bail and remanded by a Circuit Court in Accra, drawing significant public interest and legal scrutiny.
Presiding Judge Samuel Bright Acquah justified the decision by citing the sensitive nature of the case and its potential impact on national security.
“While the charges may seem minor, we must consider the broader implications—especially the accused’s comments about the Inspector General of Police,” said the judge.
“Such remarks could erode public trust in our security institutions and disturb national peace.”
In court, Judge Acquah referenced Animal Farm to support his view that people in positions of influence, like Abronye DC, must be held to a higher standard of accountability due to their potential to destabilize public order.
Amidu's Final Word
Amidu cautioned that turning the judiciary into an arm of political or authoritarian control would harm Ghana’s democratic values and institutions.
“Ghana is a constitutional democracy—not an Animal Farm,” he concluded.
Let me know if you'd like a shorter or more formal version as well.
Drop your comment if you have anything to say about this story on the comment section. Thank you
.jpeg)
.jpeg)
.jpeg)
.jpeg)
0 Comments